Battle of the bags:

Mini versus Maxi

Battle of the bags:

Mini versus Maxi

Cats or dogs? Sweet or salty? Pasta or pizza? While we’re trying to be more down-the-middle about many aspects of life, certain cases demand decisiveness. That’s where we are right now, as Bag World is split into two camps: Team Mini and Team Maxi. Let’s unpack the stories behind both trends and declare this a trend battle. Yup, it’s handbags at dawn…

Team Mini

Milan Fashion Week AW20 street style (Shutterstock)

Although minuscule bags are nothing new (the ancient Egyptians used pouches; tie-on pockets were around in the 14th century), the current trend for bags that are more breadcrumb than Baguette tracks back to Karl Lagerfeld’s tiny Peekaboo bags for Fendi SS15. Jacquemus (which just launched a pop-up at Selfridges London) went even further: the matryoshka-esque evolution of its bags started with classic top-handle styles for AW17 and shrunk down to SS20’s Le petit Chiquito (emphasis on the ‘petit’). Then came Lizzo. She set social media alight after posing with a limited-edition VSLING toybag created by Valentino and Instagram prankster @obviousplant. Now you can take your pick of mini-mes from the likes of Burberry, Chanel, Gelareh Mizrahi, Loewe and Manu Atelier (to name a few).

Milan Fashion Week AW20 street style (Shutterstock)
Chanel Métiers d'Art 2019/20 runway (Shutterstock)

Are these accessories little more than a clever ploy to lap up the social media buzz? Call them mini, micro, nano or simply very little: the smaller these teeny-tiny bags become, the more attention they seem to get – at last count, #minibag has racked up 719k associated Instagram posts. But! Aside from looking cute, these bags are also perfect if you want to declutter (we store our lives on our smartphones anyway, right?). Our Fashion Marketing Lead, Victoria Meekings, sees their practical side – at least when it comes to those that are purpose-built for one single item, such as Chanel’s quilted flask bag, or her own Prada cross-body iPhone carrier: “I get the benefit of not smashing or losing my phone while styling my outfits with a Prada accessory via a more accessible price-point than a handbag.”


 

Given that many of these minis have the capacity to hold next to nothing – my mini Le Chiquito currently hosts my lucky coin at a squeeze – the attraction for me lies in the impractical wonderfulness of layering as many of these teensy-tiny, super-cute accessories as possible.

– Fashion Marketing Lead Victoria Meekings

Jacquemus AW19 backstage (Shutterstock), Lizzo at the 2019 AMAs (Shutterstock)
Jacquemus AW19 backstage (Shutterstock)

Maybe, though, we’re going about this all wrong. Google’s definition of a bag is “a flexible container with an opening at the top, used for carrying things” – that’s things, plural. These “bags” are completely divorced from any practical purpose, so perhaps we should think of them as purely decorative and call them jewellery instead. Attention-grabbing jewellery, at that. We might need to rethink the rules for this particular battle.

Team Maxi

@thebigbagclub

As for impact? From IKEA’s OG Frakta carrier bag (and its Balenciaga glow-up in 2017) to Bottega Veneta’s SS20 Jodie, these outsized totes are quite literally hard to miss. They rival the social-media buzz of their compact counterparts, too: there’s an entire Instagram account, @thebigbagclub, dedicated to editing bags so they barely fit in the frame. The graphic designer behind it, Virginia Rolle, thinks of bags as “the real protagonists of every look”. Her account was born out of disbelief at the scale of a Gucci Marmont bag she saw on Instagram: “At the beginning, I thought that it was a fashion meme, a joke. Then I found out that it was real and I started to imagine all the bags in a larger size.”

@thebigbagclub

Brace your shoulders and gather all your belongings – big bags are here to answer the prayers of over-preparers, gym-then-work-then-dinner people and out-and-out maximalists. Outsized bags have an easier time of it when arguing their corner is concerned: bags, as we have established, are intended to hold things, and you could fit an entire week’s wardrobe, the complete contents of your bathroom cabinet and a Labrador puppy inside a holdall 2.0.

@thebigbagclub


 

At the beginning, I thought that it was a fashion meme, a joke. Then I found out that it was real and I started to imagine all the bags in a larger size.

– Virginia Rolle, Founder of @thebigbagclub

Jacquemus SS19 runway (Jason Lloyd-Evans)

With this growing trend, it has become increasingly difficult to tell meme from reality – Virginia notes: “It’s funny to see how ‘my bags’ blend perfectly into the equally huge ones by Jacquemus and Bottega Veneta.” They entertain, defy belief and make the surreal, real. Do borderline-too-practical bags incite over-packing and aching arms? Perhaps. Is it worth it for the Big Bag Energy you exude by taking up loads of space? It’s up to you to size up this argument.


The new icons

We read between the stitches of five of the season’s (super)hero bags to explore how fashion houses are using their accessories to signpost what they stand for today, and what we can expect to see from them in years to come.

Read & shop